Eric Malzone: Everybody, welcome to the Future of Fitness, a top-rated fitness industry podcast for over four years and running. I'm your host, Eric Falzone, and I have the absolute pleasure of talking to entrepreneurs, executives, thought leaders, and cutting-edge technology experts within the extremely fast-paced industries of fitness, wellness, and health sciences. Please stop by futurefitness.co to subscribe and get our interviews and summaries delivered straight to your inbox. You'll also find our free industry report on artificial intelligence. Five industry experts, five different opinions, and tons of valuable insights for free at futurefitness.co. Thanks for listening and on to the show. Hey friends, this episode of the Future of Fitness is proudly brought to you by TeamUp. Since launching in 2012, they've consistently had one mission: facilitate the best customer experiences with the most
Eric Malzone: cutting-edge solution for franchises, studios, gyms, and boxes. At its core, Teamup is a tech solution for businesses looking to unlock their next phase of growth with the most reliable partner in technology on the market. Spanning over 4,000 clients in 40 plus countries, Teamup has a vast global network with its roots right here in North America. Whether it's AI, new features, new partnerships, and new markets, TeamUp's sites are set on raising the far of the industry to enable their customers to perform and operate at the highest level locally, nationally, and over speeds. Powered by the most reliable APIs on the market, you can deliver premium customer experiences and scale-your fittest enterprise with the strongest technological infrastructure our industry has to offer. Empower your staff, engage your members, and unlock your next chapter of growth with software design for you. Learn more at goteamup.com. That is G-O-T-E-A-N-U-P.com.
Eric Malzone: We are live, the one and only Mr. Mark Fisher. Welcome back, my friend. Here we go, buddy. Great, great to be back. I'm in shock. It's been two years. Oh my gosh. It's wild. It's wild. It blew my mind. I was like, how long has it been since I've had Mark on? And then I then I look back, I'm like, oh, it was September of 2022. I mean, that probably meant that we recorded around June or July. Either way, it's uh I don't know. It's just weird post-pandemic timing.
Yeah, I would have perhaps not had a baby yet, or maybe I had just become a father last we chatted.
Eric Malzone: Yeah, I believe so. I think you were I think uh you were just about to have your baby. I can't remember, but it was close. It was very close.
Well, it just happened. It happened, Dark. Just one. Yes, it happened. So if anybody's uh catching up with anticipation of what happened, she she was born, she is a live little person, uh, and I will be going to pick her up from daycare after this this very chat.
Eric Malzone: Yeah, right on, man. Well, I know you've got a lot going on. I have uh you have a new book. We'll talk about that. Yeah, you've made some moves with Mark Fisher Fitness. Last time we were chatting, you had just uh you're looking to invest in the alloy, kind of a big announcement. So let's kick it off from there, man. What is new? What's going on over the last two years? Wow, all the things. Where do we begin?
Well, I guess I'll take it from the top. So still have Mark Fisher Fitness. I still have that. That business is running along now with a lot less from me. So to be clear there, I have uh certainly still have 50-50 ownership, but I have taken a big step back operationally and officially don't even have a I'm no longer the org charge, right? So I work with the general manager and the we call her director of possibilities, but the sales director is what a not crazy person would call her. So I'm still working with and supporting them. And yeah, you know, the the weirdest thing about that biz I'll say is still got a lot of Zoom ninjas, Eric. I still have a couple hundred people just do the Zoom workouts. I don't even feel like I can say I still have, but the team still has. So that remains both cool and an interesting operational thing that's challenging. So, you know, I think the leadership team over there, with me along, all of us, we're having some conversations around okay, what what does this mean
for the long haul? We really like this program and we're happy it's so valuable for people. As you might imagine, it can actually be also quite profitable to run, but it just really adds a lot of operational complexity. So I know that that business right now, which over the years I've spoken of is a beautiful, delightful, magical mess operationally, because it's just so complicated because I didn't know what I was doing. Uh, so a lot of the work over there is figuring out, okay, we have this thing we love. What kind of options do we have to actually make this streamline in a way that that leadership team, uh, which is interested in potentially scaling it, if they can find the right path forward to make that happen. So and the you know, the honest answer is it's gonna probably require really cracking some eggs and doing some hard things because the reason we haven't historically streamlined the model over the years is any kind of streamlining means people are gonna be disappointed, right? And there's only so much a given business can bear. So I think that is an interesting little thing over there that we're working on.
But overall, you know, happy the business is it's just remarkable now. It's like past coming up on our 14th year, our 15th year, which is just like so shocking to me. So, so that is still fun, still obviously a big part of my life and a big part of my heart. And then Alloy is now open. So, you know, as these things go, interesting update for listeners. So, two years ago we were talking about it. I think we were uh getting excited about what that was gonna be. And I'll tell you what, we didn't actually wind up opening until this the end of October. Uh, this is being recorded in August. So we are whatever that works out to be, I guess, like nine months open, 10 months open. Um, happy to dig into more details there if that's of interest, if we want to go down that route. But you know, I'll say in brief, as to be expected, there were some things that we figured out in real time. Uh, specifically had some staffing challenges up front, which are now settled. And I have someone who's just amazing as the fitness director. And that model, unlike Mark Fisher Fitness, because it's so vain and it's so
light from a people perspective, you really got to have the right people in the right seats. And we feel we've really gotten there, but that was actually only about a month and a half ago we got there. So uh, but overall, that business, you know, is so challenging and frustrating and not fun when it's not the right people, which is my responsibility to have the right people. And it's a lot more fun when you have the right people because it's like compared to MFF. It is a simple, simple model. So anyway, I've definitely learned some things there that uh inform how I'm thinking about running gyms and gym marketing. So I'll put a pin in that there in case anything highlights your curiosity. And I'll say very briefly the third business is the consulting and the coaching. That company's business for unicorns. That is the company that released this little book of Jim Mark and Secrets. And I think it's fair to say that's actually my day job. So although I'm you know an owner of Mark Fisher Fitness and an owner of Alloy, I only really get involved in those businesses operationally when there's either a specific project that requires flexing up, andor I need to come in and really help fix
something, speaking candidly. So now happily, both those businesses are in a situation where I'm not doing quite as much with that. And Business for Unicorns has grown a lot in the past, uh, particularly in the past like six months since we decided we were going to actually really get focused and thought there was a there, there, and got to the place we felt like, okay, after doing this informally now for several years, we feel very confident that these operations are baked out. I, you know, you can't ever quite say it's a factory, but we got to the point where we had enough quantifiable, speaking candidly, financial success with enough gym owners that we felt that we were in a position now that we could handle a little bit more scale because we knew that we had the goods to help people if they came to us asking for help. The things we know we're good at, we're gonna we're gonna really deliver for them. So I'll pull up there. That's uh that's my tour of my world. And I'm sure you'll have places you want to dig in more and shine lights on and dig out with a shovel.
Eric Malzone: Yeah, yeah, as always. Uh I do. So I want to get back to the the the Zoom warriors, I believe. Or Zoom ninjas. Yeah, yeah. Where uh that's that's fascinating, dude. Like, are they all in Manhattan or are they kind of starting to spread out? Like we're looking for spread out.
There, I mean, there's certainly many in the New York City area. There is some percentage in other markets, right? And this is their way of training with Mark Fisher Fitness. But, you know, there's a non-zero percentage of them that are even near the clubhouse and probably could come in physically, but just choose not to, right? And there's a number of reasons for that. I think certainly that product is very good. Now, again, it's challenging because it's so different from the other products. The type of fulfillment there requires, as you might imagine, a really good banter, right? So it doesn't require because you really can't utilize very intense, deep technical, biomechanical coaching over Zoom. Though, again, I gotta say, these coaches, they work their ass off because they will work that Zoom grid. They're saying names, they're asking people adjust their camera, they're coaching. I don't want to make it sound like they're not coaching, but there's obviously some limitations doing it through a screen, right? Um, and then further, there is really a premium on are you funny, right? Are you able to keep
a pattern going that has people engaged and amused and inspired? And compared to another service, like let's say something like small group personal training, certainly communication still matters, but it's a very different product with a very different set of deliverables that that coach needs to share. So yeah, it's it's an interesting because I suspect some of those individuals might be willing to come and train in person if we just took away that option. We don't have any intention to take away that option, but it, you know, certainly it's not a program that is growing at this point. And that is the thing that's making a little bit of a sticky moment over there is we're figuring out, okay, what is the path to make MFF simpler? But also, you know, that that service line is comfortably larger than the average the revenue of the average gym in America. So it's hard to just be like, well, we're just gonna cancel it. And you know, to say nothing
of the people that so uh find so much value in that program. So that's a thing that you know the operations team is figuring out over there. And uh, you know, another thing I'll share too that is interesting that we are also grappling with is that particular street. And this is a little bit New York, I think, compared to maybe other markets, but that particular street has really not recovered from COVID. And I don't mean economically, though, that's probably true too. I mean there's been a meaningful uptick of gnarly behavior on that street. And that too has presented issues. And our landlord's wonderful, but what it's meant in practice is we had to put in a story and a half, basically gate in front of the clubhouse so that people wouldn't jump into the downstairs entry to the basement to have sex and do drugs. We had to put in front prison style floodlights. We they put in, again, this is actually to my landlord's credit, to be very clear, I mean this, I appreciate that they did this, but you might imagine having to put spikes on the fire hydrants out front because so many people hang
out there is not the best. And it can get quite scary actually in the mornings and evening. So, you know, uh, I I think I can probably share this as I think this is probably not news to anybody, and there's no plans to do anything yet. So if a ninja's listening or team members listening, don't panic. But yeah, I think it's probably not a secret to anybody. One of the things we're gonna have to consider is probably finding another location. At least consider. Again, maybe we hopefully we can make it work there, but I don't know. It's just tough because of our proximity to Port Authority and the fact there's no other buildings on that street. And anybody that runs any sort of brick and mortar business realizes that's gonna have a quiet but meaningful drag on everything from retention to, you know, God forbid somebody comes there to try us out, and there are unhoused people sleeping on the street in front of the clubhouse. It's it's really becoming uh a point of I know frustration and concern for the team and the ninjas alike. So that is another thing that is uh, you know, part of the joys of running all these businesses is Eric, all these various things. And that's that's the thing over there that is getting
discussed.
Eric Malzone: Yeah, you know, it's funny. I uh I think you may, we may have talked about this last time, but running a gym, it's like the operations, the programming, it's generally like the least of your concerns, man. I call them the parking lot issues. Right. You know, it's just like stuff that happens, like it's just completely out of your control. You're like, what? Like, who's sleeping with who? Wait, like what is going on? It's just these things that you can't you can't quite control. You never saw coming. Yeah, but I guess it's just part of doing business. And uh let's say, well, so let's talk about business for unicorns and what you guys are doing there. So when a person says consulting, it's rather vague. Yep, right? Like most of the time when I tell people I consult, they're like, Oh, I think he's CIA. Uh, but you know, I'm I'm not. If anyone is wondering, I'm not CIA. But when you say consulting, and there's a there's a decent amount of consultants within gym space, like who are you guys working with? How are you guys differentiating? And why are you seeing so much growth over the last six months?
Yeah, so to speak a little bit to who we're working with, we work specifically with independent, for the most part, actually, we that's a that's a lie. We now work franchises. That's a lie, Eric. We're going quickly. So historically, it has been independent gym owners with one to three locations. We do require a revenue minimum for the core offering, which we call the Unicorn Society, which is a 12-month coaching program. We do ask for a $15,000 per month minimum. So these are for the most part not a brand new baby turtle, though, admittedly, that revenue threshold plays very differently in different markets. It is also important to know we work with individuals that make their revenue through selling coaching products, with the vast majority being some sort of group product, either small group, large group, or some combination. So we do work with a handful of individuals that offer personal training. And some of our members also offer an open access option. But for the most part, our services
are geared around how do we help this type of gym owner with this type of service create more income, more impact, and more freedom. Because we feel very strongly that you really need all three of these. Uh, there's a lot of gym owners out there that know they're making great impact, but are very frustrated because it's very scary to look at their bank app and they feel someone changed the facility. Then I think there's another tier above there where people know they're making good money and they feel like they're doing a great job with the clients, but they haven't really been able to build a team to give themselves any kind of freedom, which also is not ideal. So that is the broad strokes of that program. And that's really the only thing people can do with us. Now, you're welcome to come to an extra seat to retreats, which we do a couple of times a year. Uh, occasionally we'll offer like a course or something smaller. But besides the main program, the only other thing we offer is a 12-week marketing sprint. And that's for gym owners that either are not ready for the Unicorn Society or want to focus only on income.
So if you only want to talk about getting more leads and getting more clients, it's a 12-week market sprint. It's the only thing we talk about in there. There's nothing about operations except for me saying, in a way that I have to say that this doesn't work if the service is not good, right? If you fill the hole faster and there's a big hole at the bottom of the bucket, that's not it. But assuming a gym owner is, let's say, very good at what they're offering, but they just really, like a lot of gym owners, like me, they opened up their gym without an understanding of both the principles of marketing as well as the specific tactics and strategies that are working, specifically now in 2024, which is different than it was even five years ago, certainly 10 years ago. And that is the other way that people can work with us.
Eric Malzone: Awesome, man. I want to tap into your experience over the last 15 years as a gym owner. Because I think that's a really interesting time frame. A lot has happened. I mean, you kind of started, I think, you know, I started my gym in 08. So it was like, you know, kind of post-financial crash. And that was a legitimate financial crash. Yeah. Uh, and then, you know, pandemic, of course, you know, a lot of a lot of things have happened over the last 15 years for gym owners. So, you know, how if you can just maybe broadly a broad scope, like how has the gym industry, we'll just talk about independent gym owners, how has it changed over the last 15 years significantly, do you think? And then I want to get into the marketing specifically.
Yeah. I mean, there's two that come to mind. The first is, and I think this is this has some pros and cons to it, but I have a theory of what I call the theory of displaced nutrients. So the first way that I see gyms having changed in a meaningful way over the past 15 years is it used to be when guys like us were coming up, there wasn't a lot of information at all about the business of fitness. And if you were really uh ambitious and nerdy, at least by the time I opened up Mark Fisher Fitness or started getting serious about it, 2010, 2011, at least by that time, there were a couple people talking about fitness business, but for the most part, there were only a couple of them. And there wasn't that many resources where they were putting out tons of content necessarily. You would see them maybe at event. There might be one or two business speakers, and a lot of the learning that you would do would be through books. You'd read business books, which may or may not apply to a gym, because obviously
most business books, maybe not obviously, but many business books are written as essentially business cards for corporate consultants to book much larger companies that have the amount of revenue necessary to hire people and consultants for very large consulting gigs. So that's not that's not to say that I don't get a lot of value out of a lot of business books, but as somebody that's been reading, you know, one to two books per week for my career at this point, a lot of them at this point are feeling more and more flimsy. Like this was a pamphlet, and you couldn't just give them your framework, your, you know, your whatever your XY access, whatever your model is, you had to write a book around it, and then you had to like put all your friends in a chokehole to get on some obscure bookseller list, because now instead of you know 10K for the day, now you can search 25K for the day and get business class, right? Uh and I don't judge any of that, but I just want to point that out because if you're listening to this, particularly if you are a smaller gym owner, a brick and mortar business, it's not that that's a bad idea to read books like Good to Great. You
should absolutely read that. There's, I think, principles that are still useful, but it's so far into what your experience is like running a gym where you have like, you know, three employees, you maybe make a hire once every 18 months, just a very different scale of business. So I say all that to point out that this is very different now. So now there's tons of guys like me, like us, there's a lot of resources. There's, I think, God, there has to be like 30 podcasts just devoted even to my particular niche of the fitness business. There are all sorts of coaching groups, there are all sorts of courses, products. You know, if you go to events like Perform Better, where I speak on the tour, you know, instead of there being one or two people now, usually any given weekend, there's, you know, three to five to six different speakers that are talking about the business. And I think net net, it's a positive in a lot of ways because we're still a young industry. And in particular, my corner oftentimes is often defined by being a personal
trainer that opened up a gym, which is very different than a business person that opened up a gym because they wanted to get into business. Right. And it's not to say that either are better than the other, just that if you come from a personal trainer background, you often need a lot of those gaps filled in to understand the basics of marketing and sales and finance and hiring and managing and developing a team. So I think that's good. But I do think because of that, there is maybe a generation of younger coaches and gym owners that have not had nearly the amount of in-person educational experience. And my suspicion is it might have maybe in not helpful ways diluted the actual quality of the technical training fitness product. And I want to be clear because I am not a zealot at all. I from a public health messaging perspective, I want people moving, right? I want everybody going for aggressive walks every day. If we do that, I've always been more interested in raising our floor as a society than necessarily optimizing into the far ether for the people that are, you
know, amazing, inspiring freaks of nature that are so, so fit. However, if the quality of training at the prototypical training gym is just not that great, because instead of the owner going to starting strength seminar or really being diligent about studying the FMS or getting, you know, a crossert or whatever, if very early on in their career they started diffusing a lot of their time and attention, just focusing on making more money, that can come with a cost. And again, that is, I think, a very, very big change from 15 years ago. So I have a uh some other things I'll share, but I'll kind of pull up there in case you had any follow-up questions or any uh reflections or insights.
Eric Malzone: No, I mean it's it it definitely seems that I mean, here's my take, too, is we talk about business people who get into fitness, like it it seems rare because if you're truly a fitness uh business mind, you wouldn't do it. Are you gonna choose fitness?
Or or if you did, you wouldn't be opening up like one small brick and mortar. Now, admittedly, you might be doing franchising, right? Like you might go into a franchise, but and even then, uh, if you really want big enterprise value, you're likely doing something related to tech that has the capacity for real enterprise value and real scale. And that's just a game that has almost no resemblance to what the typical A personal trainer who opened up a small gym in Nebraska. They're again same industry kind of, but there's almost no crossover. Yeah.
Eric Malzone: I mean, it's uh you know, you see like these big executives shuffle. I just talked about the CU shuffle to all these large major companies within the fitness industry that are on Wall Street. And it's like, you know, when guys from Taco Bell, I'm like, I can already say I don't think this is gonna work out well. You know, I mean, maybe it is, but I can just tell you right now, it's a lot easier to sell Gorditos than it is to sell, you know, fat loss or you know fitness as a as a lifestyle, right? It's just it takes more, more emotion to get to that point. So it's it is interesting. And I want to get your take on this because I've heard multiple different things about this, especially with the advent of AI. But how do you feel like the fitness profession? When I say the profession, I mean the practitioners, the coaches, the trainers. How do you feel like that profession is doing? Like is it is it are you optimistic about it or are you a little like I'm concerned it's sliding into the gig economy, or it's just kind of a thing you do for a little while and then you move on? Like, are people looking for a career where they could spend 10, 15 years or more in as a practitioner? Or what do you what's your take on that?
Yeah, I mean, uh the first thing I'll qualify is I don't have any data on this, right? So I can't I'll share like my like this is what feels right to me because obviously, you know, the industry is large. I mean, there has to be, I can't remember the exact numbers, but I think there's like over 100,000 trainers, maybe multiple hundreds of thousands trainers just in the US.
Eric Malzone: Hey friends, Eric Malzone here. I've had the honor of interviewing over 750 professionals across the fitness, health, and wellness industries. There's one thing I know for sure. Without a doubt, there is a tremendous opportunity to leverage a highly valuable and relatively untapped network of independent podcasters and content creators. Traditional advertising isn't what it used to be. End result first hand industry, there's a much better way to connect with your target audience and emergency top leader in the industry. That's exactly what I've watched podcasts like. Ultimate solution is like two power executives, founders, top leaders in the finite optimist, leverage the extraordinary opportunities and network infinite podcasts. Don't just push your podcast to make you unfortunately. One of my coaching issues that you should write message, provide audience, confident, and squat. We create five-topping
Eric Malzone: digital assets and social media overflows to ensure that you are optimizing each and every period. Introductions to strategic partners, a potential enterprise client provide unparalleled value, and only a professional network like ours can offer. We work with a very limited number of clients to ensure the highest level of service. So please don't hesitate to reach out and learn more. Go to podcastcollective.io to learn more and contact me directly. That's podcastcollective.io.
So I know this. One of the challenges for the industry is if you look at the business model, it's there's just not that much to go around. You don't get unlimited scale. So follow me on this very strange uh analogy, which I promise is going to relate back to this. So one of the issues we have in society, Eric, is childcare. Right. And the reason childcare is such a sticky widget is it doesn't scale, right? Like you can't have like one person can only manage so many two-year-olds, so many three-year-olds. The robots can't do much to help there yet. So you have this perverse situation where the market is such that because at current, the way the United States particularly set up and there's not a lot of subsidiation for this, what happens is well, for one person to make enough living off only taking care of four to eight kids and also having all the overhead associated with having a physical space, it kind of doesn't work for anybody, right? Because you have to charge
the couples so much money, and then you're still not really making a lot of money as a business, and you still can't really pay the people that are doing the care tons. It's tough. Now, again, that's not my world, right? So I don't have the solutions there, other than yes, perhaps the state does need to subsidize that that kind of care. But it's it's challenging, right? Because the only way you could potentially do it is you just keep raising the rates of the daycare until at a certain point the parents say, This doesn't make sense. If you look at the net income impact on our family, one partner, and it's usually the woman, will just leave the workforce. They'll just leave the workforce because it doesn't make sense uh for a lot of people, unless you're doing really well, to spend, you know, $25,000 to $50,000 a year on your daycare for your two-year-old or your three-year-old, right? It's not, it's not a very scalable or sustainable model for the society. Well, I say this because if you look at the training gym, it's not dissimilar. So the hypothetical training gym with what's called 100 to 250 clients,
the way the math works, you either have to go pretty massively upmarket and charge a lot of money to people that have discretionary income, which are usually only going to be people that are older. And even then, for the gym owner to get very good margins, there's a limit on what you can pay the staff, right? So without getting into details about anything I'm not allowed to talk about because of whatever FTD uh, you know, disclosure I can or can't make. One of the things I really like about Alloy, right? And part of how they've solved it that I like is just make the model super, super lean. And I'm also the first to admit Alloy is not out there trying to be like a discount provider by any means, right? We're premium priced products, right? It's not a high quality product, but by I'm not the person to say it's cheap. Uh, that's part of the rationale behind being a Fit 40 and over a crowd. But even so, particularly compared to the types of one-on-one training or other products they might provide. What I like about Alloy is it's a great value proposition for the consumer. It's a great value proposition for the business owner because you can
get the margins right because it's being run so operationally lean that you can actually pay people pretty good rates for what this job is. So we go back to your question: is this industry at the risk of people becoming more gigging? I'm not sure necessarily that was ever the case, but one thing that's new compared to 15 years ago is the advent of online training. So, one threat certainly to many gym owners, at least in theory, in theory, and I'll come back to that. At least in theory, is now your trainers, instead of the only other option being applying their trade at the local independent gym spot where they're renting by the hour or the month. And a certain point they're like, I just don't want to do the marketing stuff. I'd rather just make a little less money and I'll come work with you and just feed me clients, and I can just train and just do the thing I want to do. Well, now some of them, some percentage of them, are able to go train online and in some situations, maybe even make less money than they were making doing their in-person training, but they're fine with it. Because if you're in a smaller market, maybe you'd rather
just make $40,000 a year and not really have to be anywhere and be able to move to somewhere with a very low cost of living. Maybe do geo arbitrage. You're going to go live in Thailand for a couple of years. Now, again, is that making a sustainable career? Maybe not, but at least it's one more option for trainers to consider. It's, I don't think it's taking anyway from the gyms. I've always felt that because I think the consumer that wants that product for the most part wasn't going to buy a $300, $400, $500 training gym membership necessarily. So to my mind, I'm happy for there to be more options for people to get help with fitness. I'm happy for there to be more professional opportunities for people in the industry. But again, it's hard to speak to like the broader picture of has anybody figured out a way to scale fitness such that the model really works beautifully for everybody. It's hard to say. It's hard to say. I think it's not like horribly broken, but but you know, it's I I'm not the first person to lose a little sleep over what sort of career prospects are we offering for people in this industry?
How do we make it so not just gym owners like myself, but the actual frontline trainers have a career? Because for the most part, the solution most people have had is we just accept it's going to be a transitory thing, right? You expect if you sign up, if you come and work at most training gyms, unless you're in a rural market and you're very happy to make X and you're not super financially ambitious, and which by the way is not a bad thing, right? I don't mean that in a derogatory way. But if you're very happy in your market making what you're making, then that's good for the gym owner to be pretty sustainable. But if you have staff that are quite ambitious, there's always going to be a cap on what you can pay in any of these models because you just don't have unlimited scale, right? You're going to have hard cost of goods sold or cost of service that's actually been our industry that's going to impact the most you can pay unless somebody's able to move into some sort of partnership or leadership position. And again, that can be great for freedom for the owner, but then also now that some of the owner's pie is getting a little bit smaller. So usually it means they're going to consider other opportunities, which may or may not be what they want to do. So
yeah, I'll pull up there, but it's it's something I think a lot about. And in short, I don't know, Eric. I don't know. What do you think?
Eric Malzone: Yeah. Oh man, I have a lot of thoughts on that, Mark. I number one is that the childcare analogy is really good. Uh and I can I can't metaphor, analogy, I can't get these right nowadays. Uh yeah. Debated on that for like five minutes on a last pod on a recent podcast. Anyways, I know it's a metaphor, an analogy.
Yeah, you're right. It's probably not a you could say analogous, but I think then we're being uh perhaps loose with the real uh definition.
Eric Malzone: Uh either way, it's a good comparison, Mark. I like it. And I think that uh one of the things I noticed as a gym owner for a while, and we did really you know decent top line revenue, uh, was that I always say there's not enough slices of the pie to go around. The pie's not that big, you know, because people come out with these like awesome, you know, uh business plans and they're like, okay, well, if you just do percentage here and percentage here, you just dish off all these percentages. I'm like, I guys, I in practicality, maybe if my gym is doing 50 grand a month, okay. I have a lot of slices I can start to get. But for most people to get to that point, it's just not like that. So I think you're right. I mean, it is a fundamental issue, and I do like lean. I mean, if I was ever could open another gym, it would be something in the small group or personal training model because you can just do it very effectively. You can have a couple good key employees, you can make them happy. They love what they're due because they're not having to handle all this operational bullshit for the most part, right? It's just very clean. And the online coaching thing is really interesting. Now, I get the allure, right? Everyone loves the thought of sitting in Bali on a, you know, on a beach
Eric Malzone: with their laptops and just total freedom, right? It's a it's a lovely thought. Uh, but but the reality is that's a completely different skill set. You obviously now you have to learn marketing, you have to learn content, you have to learn sales, you have to niche down, you have to do all these things, continue to get leads because it's not easy to get online leads. Uh so I think there's a little bit of uh I was just having this conversation with a good friend of mine. He's an awesome coach, dude. He's like one of the best like uh action sport coaches I know. And whenever he tries to go online, he's like, I just I don't I don't know how to get new leads. You know, I'm I'm really good here locally where I live. And that that's a big deal. It's like you have to start doing content, you have to do all these things you probably hate to do. So more people go that path.
Yeah, it's I mean it's certainly possible in theory, but you make a good point. I think the thing is it's so much more competitive. It's so much more competitive. And you can argue that, like, yes, listen, somebody's got to win, but when you remove the geographic constraint, you know, you're competing against everybody else, to say nothing of the fact that there are still a lot of consumers that don't want that type of training. And again, there are some that's actually the better fit. They're like, just give me my program or we do a call once a month or whatever. And there are people that do it really, really, really well. But yeah, you're, you know, there's higher potential return at least, but you're playing in a much, much more uh crowded ball game because you don't have the geographic mode, right? Whereas a gym, you're only ever gonna be able to be uh competing with other people that could physically get to your facility and they might go somewhere else.
Eric Malzone: Yeah. And I think one of the things that if you are gonna go online, then I would urge you is like you have to start to understand what a building a brand is. Like I a brand came across um someone who does really well in the online space. Uh her name's Kelly, I can't remember her last name, but Western workouts is the name of the business. So she's she's a she's a cowboy. Cowboy love it, right? Like, and she does work out specific to that stuff. She's very niche down, she's got great social media presence. She's a brand, man. Like that's it's it's really good, and she's gonna do really well because she took a long time to you know develop that niche and that brand. So I think that's something that people need to consider. I want to give us enough time for something here, Mark, because like, okay, I asked you about how the gym business has changed over the last 15 years, but specifically, like, how has gym marketing changed over the last 15 years? Because that's been a significant, certainly significant shift. I mean, I remember there was no Facebook ads.
I know, me too, bro. Me too. And and not only that, I remember this is the weird things about the early days of MFF. I remember when organic Facebook in retrospect drove a lot of brand awareness for us. It drove both uh people finding out we existed because people were posting about us on Facebook and tagging us. It also helped create like and trust, particularly because I was very lucky. Broadway had the unique distinction of being a very insular community based around a specific neighborhood that was on the one hand small, but the other hand was big. There's a lot of people that are involved in the Broadway community, and a lot of them knew each other. So organic Facebook was very, very important for Mark Fisher Fitness in the beginning. And it wouldn't play that way today. I mean, again, maybe if we went back in time and Instagram was, you know, a couple years older, perhaps we could have done some of it. Instagram also is always changing, and you gotta imagine it's only a matter of time before Instagram's organic reach goes down. And I think we're already seeing that's happening over and
over. It's gonna become a pay-to-play market as well. But yeah, there were no Facebook ads. But, you know, listen, children sit on grandpa Marquis knee. Uh yeah, I used to like write a lot of news feed updates in Facebook that really helped build awareness for what MFF was, built my personal brand within that community, and really meaningfully drove business. Now, the thing that's interesting about the time when I got in was a few years before Facebook ads, and we were already in a digital world where the thing that's interesting when I think about what MFF did well at the time, which I think has remained the same, is we did it and some of this stuff again, Jim MarketingSecrets Book.com. If you want to find more of these tales, you can go to uh get the free download of this book that I wrote that covers all the ways you can get more leads and more clients. And one of my favorite strategies I have people always start with is well, who are the people you know and can you start talking to them, right? Now, the difference was talking to the people you know was really only an email game in 2008, 2009.
Talking to people you know in 2024, I think email is a very important part of that. But uh, and I don't know necessarily that I would just start actually like doing text marketing to people to haven't explicitly opt-in. That sounds bad for them. But a lot of the game is people that already know you should understand what it is that you're offering, right? And in 2010, what I did was I started talking to all the people that I knew. And I just happened to know a lot of people because I was an actor and I did maybe 40 to 50 shows in my professional career. So I was not shy about putting myself out there and making offers to those people. So to some extent, I didn't have to do a lot of the lead generation that another gym is going to have to do because I just already knew a lot of people and I was also very good at what I did. So I had a critical mass of clients very quickly, all of whom were dragging their friends in by their hair. Now, this is interesting because as things progressed, obviously the biggest change in marketing over the past 15,
even 10 years is the advent of paid digital, both paid Google ads uh and paid, we'll call it meta, but Facebook ads, Instagram ads. Well, when that started happening in 2015, 2016, we were very late to the party. Honestly, even 2017, 2018, we ran ads, we didn't really know what we were doing. So everybody talks about 2017 as these halcyon days where everyone was getting $2 leads and everyone just showing up and they were just getting sold into it. We totally missed that because we didn't have any fitness industry specific skill in it. We had some people that had some experience doing paid digital from other industries. I don't know, I can't say necessarily we did a bad job, but as an example of how not on it we were, at least for me for my role at that time, I can't even really I don't have any remembrance of the numbers. I'm not sure how closely we were looking at all of that. So I think Mark Fisher Fitness kind of missed out on that, but a lot of gyms didn't. And what's been interesting, the way things have changed, obviously, in the past five to seven years, is those days are
gone. So what you're seeing now is lead costs are a lot higher. If you're in a market like New York City, I always like joke, it's like trying to pet a deer. It's like trying to pet a deer because everyone has just been so blasted with paid digital marketing. I mean, everybody's in the game. It's funny, I saw an Instagram post of a gym consulting business the other day, and they were the the content was an interesting idea. They're like, I'm gonna Google 10 local businesses and see who's running ads. And only one of the people running ads, I was like, ha ha ha ha. So this is another strange thing about paid digital ads. And I think marketing strategies in general, they're highly market dependent. There are markets where people are just not burnt out, where you're gonna get cheaper leads, people are gonna be more trusting, they're gonna be easier to move through the funnel. If you're in midtown Manhattan, you're you're smoked. It's not, and again, it's not that it doesn't work, it totally works. We still drive a lot of our business from paid ads, but you have to be very sophisticated with the strategy. People are pretty burnt out, and it's gonna cost you more money than it will in a lot of other markets. And one
of the costs I think I see with a lot of gym owners, if you came up at that time, right? If you came up in 2017, 2018, and you didn't really even mess much with email marketing, you didn't really bother with talking to the people you already knew. You certainly didn't spend a lot of time building business partnerships or going into parking lots and just talking to any strangers. Because at the time it didn't make sense. It was the better use of your time and money, just like keep putting money in the Mark Zuckerberg money machine, putting a dollar in, get three dollars how, just keep doing it over and over. And then what wound up happening was every year, as that's gotten a bigger and a bigger and a bigger grind, there a lot of those gym owners from that era, I think, in some situations, never took the time, if I'm being real, to force themselves to go out there and do the uncomfortable other things that are, for the most part, going to be much slower return. It's gonna be a longer tail before you really start to see the results. But they've got to go out there and start to develop the skills. And if they don't, you're gonna run into issues, particularly if you're in a marker, page digital doesn't work the way that it does.
And then the newest gym owners that are being born, in quotes, he says, that are being born now. Well, a lot of them will open up the gym. They know about training, and they're gonna go right to paid digital right away. And oftentimes they don't really understand how to run the gym, like the operations aren't dialed in. So then they're and it's a it's a it's it's rough out there. So then you have these like gym owners that like don't necessarily know how to run a great gym or how to do the sales, the follow-up. And then they're throwing money at these ad agencies, some of which are fantastic, some of which are not as amazing because it's actually very hard to run a Facebook uh ad agency. So you see, not a lot of people uh want that job anymore because you're getting yelled at by these gym owners that are like, I'm giving this money, your leads suck, right? So, you know, overall, I think it's all going, it's all going as it should. Ever ever the optimist, I think we'll get better at this. But you know, potential takeaway for listeners are yes, you need a paid digital strategy. And I'm just curious to know
if you run a gym, if you're what else are you doing besides paid digital to grow it? And then what are your numbers? Right? Are you tracking it? What sort of results are you getting through these other things that you could do? Again, all of which are I'll plug the book again, gymmarking secretsbook.com. There's a lot of other things you could be don't doing to growing your gym besides just giving money to the market sucker.
Eric Malzone: Yeah. Awesome, man. I mean, I I just feel that uh maybe you can tell me if I'm wrong. There, there's the fundamentals, you know, you're right, they have a longer tail, but you know, local business partnerships, hosting events, doing a charity event once a year, right? Just you know, being out and introducing yourself, you know, I I think it's really yeah. I'm that's what got when I started in 08, that's what got used to. I had to ground, right? You had to. And then I was super late to. Yeah, and listen, yeah, I was super late.
You know, like at a high at a high level, like uh it's really simple. It's unfortunately simple. If you want to generate new leads, all right, let's say you're already talking to people you know, you've already organized your contact database so that if you say hello to somebody in grocery store, they know you have a gym and you're you're in contact with them because even if they don't want to work with you, they might be a referral source. Let's say you've already done that. Well, there's really other three other ways to grow a gym. You can pay for leads, give money to Google or Meta. You can ask for referrals, you can ask your clients, but everybody knows, again, like that's not an overnight thing number one. It's not like you're like, hey, client, go get me this thing. I'll give you a thousand dollars. Like it doesn't work like that. You should still do it. And I have a lot of very strong opinions about how to do that effectively. But I would note if you don't have a lot of current clients, that's gonna be of limited use to you. Well, the third strategy, the only thing you have left is meet strangers. Meet strangers. And it's gonna require putting yourself out there. And that could be anything from hand-to-hand combat in the target grocery, the target or grocery store
parking lot. It could be, as you said, Eric, running live events. If you want to get some scale, you go meet one business partner. And if they'll play ball, they will introduce you to their audience. That can be a very powerful source, but they will all of them, besides putting money in the meta or Google machine, will require you going and talking to strangers. You can do it. I feel like that's it's so dark. I'm like, you're gonna have to talk to people. But what I mean to say is you're gonna have to talk to people. Paul, I believe in you.
Eric Malzone: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, we used to hold uh ourselves accountable. So every Friday we had to come in, my business partner and I with a new business card of someone we met. Yeah. And that was it. If we didn't, we owed each other 20 bucks. And it was just like a consistent thing. It just made it kind of fun. And you're like, you never knew what was going to happen, but you just got to do it consistently over time. Yep. With the last few minutes, Mark, give us an an an update on like what's going on for Q4. You can be out speaking. You got the book. What's going on?
Let's see here. I will be so busy for Unicorns will have uh a retreat in Boston in mid-September. So I'll be there for that. Nice. Uh depending when this goes live, if anybody wants to contact me, we uh usually have a couple extra seats that we might already be sold out. But but come find me, I'll let you know. Secondly, I'll be speaking to Alloy Conference in September. That'll be very fun, a chance to meet with the rest of the system and connect with a lot of the franchise owners, which, you know, I'll say in brief, that's been one of the coolest things about being in a franchise that's hard to clock until you're in it, is just talking to other people that have the exact same business as you and comparing benchmarks, notes, KPIs. And then from there, I'll be speaking at Luca Hosovar's event Vigor Ground Summit in Seattle. And then that's all that's all I have for official work travel. But other than that, yeah, I'll just be working on all those businesses, keeping keeping the balls in the area, all balls in the air, and doing my best to be of service and support everybody that I get to work with, either as an employee or as a client. Yeah, best way to do that these days. I mean, if you want to get a hold of me personally, it's Mark at businessforunicorns.com. We're pretty active
on Instagram. So if you like gym content stuff, uh you can follow us at Business for Unicorns. And as we I have mentioned, this book I'm very, very proud of. It's less than a 30-minute read. I apologize if you like a lot of whimsy and personal branding and long elaborate stories. This is not that, right? I always joke it's like not a book. It's a power pamphlet. It's like a checklist on steroids. But if you want a list of all the things you can do to grow your gym, if you go to gymmarketingsecretsbook.com. Again, it's completely free. You'll download it. Uh, I think it's a great way to look through all the things you could do. My one caveat there, which is now in the updated intro to the book, is just don't do all of the things, right? Because I think one of the more common mistakes I tend to see after people really focusing on this is they're trying to do everything and doing everything kind of half-assy. Uh, and and again, this is still a thing I have to watch out in my businesses, right? So, like you're not alone in this. So, physician, heal thyself. Uh, but I would encourage you to read the book and then maybe just go all in on one or two things instead of doing 25 things, sort of.
Eric Malzone: Yeah, awesome, man. Mark, brother, it's always a pleasure. Uh you're always doing good stuff, but you seem to stick kind of on somewhat of a linear path. Yeah, I mean, gym gym business stuff, man. You know, you're helping the industry grow.
Yeah, I always say it's like it's like the gym run. It's like I want to learn, I want to practice, and I want to teach. I want to learn, I want to practice, and I want to teach. And yeah, I feel lucky to have a path where that is evolving in a way that I remain interested and excited and have the new thing to do, but still, you know, have some uh, you know, hopefully building up some compound return on some of the things I've been doing for a long time.
Eric Malzone: Yeah, right on. Thank you, brother. Ladies and gentlemen, Mark Fisher. Hey, wait, don't leave yet. This is your host, Eric Malzone, and I hope you enjoyed this episode of Future of Minute. If you did, I'm gonna ask you to do three simple things. It takes under five minutes and it goes such a long way. We really appreciate it. Number one, please subscribe to our show wherever you listen to it, iTunes, Spotify, Castbox, whatever it may be. Number two, please leave us a favorable review. Number three, share. Put it on social media, talk about it to your friends, send it in a text message, whatever it may be. Please share this episode because we put a lot of work into it. We want to make sure that as many people are getting value out of it as possible. Lastly, if you'd like to learn more, get in touch with me, simply go to the futurofitness.co. You can subscribe to our newsletter there, or you can simply get in touch with me as I love to hear from our listeners. So thank you so much. This is Eric Malzone, and this is the future of
Eric Malzone: fitness. Have a great day.
Why this conversation matters
Show notes by Dani
In this engaging discussion, host Eric welcomes back renowned fitness entrepreneur Mark Fisher, exploring the evolution of Mark's ventures over the past two years. Mark discusses his reduced operational role in Mark Fisher Fitness, the challenges and successes of the company's Zoom workouts, and the potential need for relocation due to post-COVID challenges in New York. He also introduces Alloy, his franchise gym model, and Business for Unicorns, a consulting and coaching company helping gym owners. Mark shares insights on changes in gym marketing, emphasizing the transition from early organic strategies to the current reliance on paid digital ads, and underscores the importance of diverse marketing tactics. The conversation also touches on the state of the fitness profession, its challenges, and the opportunities for growth through innovative business models. Mark closes by sharing future plans and his commitment to supporting the fitness industry's evolution.